Best Pet Insurance Companies of 2024

Easily compare the best pet insurance options and make an informed decision to safeguard your pet’s health and well-being while preserving your financial stability. Whether it’s routine check-ups, emergencies, or chronic illnesses, pet insurance is the key to ensuring your pets enjoy a happy, healthy life without causing you to break the bank.

Last Updated: January 1, 2024

Lexington Law


  • Best overall coverage & rates

  • Fast claim reimbursement powered by AI

  • Pre insurance pet exam not required

  • Multi-pet discount available

Animalia Pet Insurance Review


  • Focused on cat & dog insurance

  • Short, 5 day waiting period for coverage

  • Curable, pre-existing conditions are covered

  • Extra benefits included in coverage at no extra charge

Pin Paws Pet Insurance Review

Pin Paws

  • 3 monthly membership plans available

  • Insurance plans offered through MetLife

  • Coverage for all pets in your home

  • Included pet tag for location tracking

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Review


  • Extensive accident & illness coverage

  • 90% cash back on eligible vet bills

  • Includes dental illnesses, behavioral issues & hereditary conditions

  • Coverage includes kittens and puppies

Pets Best

  • Unlimited annual or lifetime benefit plan

  • One annual deductible

  • 24/7 pet helpline included

  • No upper age limits on accident & illness plans

Hello Genius Pet Insurance Buyer’s Guide

What is Pet Insurance?

Pet insurance is a financial safety net designed to cover the medical expenses associated with your furry friends. Just like human health insurance, it provides coverage for a range of veterinary services, from routine check-ups and vaccinations to unexpected accidents and illnesses. When you have pet insurance, you can rest easy knowing that you won’t have to make difficult decisions about your pet’s healthcare based on your ability to pay. Instead, you can focus on what matters most: providing the best possible care for your beloved animal companions.

What are the benefits of pet insurance?

There are several compelling reasons to have pet insurance. First and foremost, it ensures that your pets receive prompt and high-quality medical attention when they need it the most. In emergencies, time is of the essence, and pet insurance can mean the difference between life and death for your pet.

Furthermore, pet insurance can ease the financial strain that veterinary bills can impose, as medical treatments for pets can be surprisingly expensive. Without insurance, a serious illness or injury can lead to unexpected and substantial costs.

With pet insurance, you can budget for your pet’s healthcare with predictable monthly premiums, making it easier to manage your finances and prioritize your pet’s well-being. Overall, pet insurance offers peace of mind, allowing you to make healthcare decisions for your pets based on their needs rather than financial constraints.

How to choose the best pet insurance for your needs

Choosing the right pet insurance plan requires careful consideration of several key factors to ensure that you select a policy that aligns with your pet’s needs and your budget. Here are some essential factors to keep in mind:

1. Coverage Options: Evaluate what each policy covers, including routine care, accidents, illnesses, hereditary conditions, and pre-existing conditions. Some plans may also cover prescription medications, dental care, and alternative therapies. Choose a policy that offers coverage for the specific needs of your pet.

2. Deductibles and Premiums: Understand the deductible (the amount you must pay before the insurance kicks in) and the monthly premiums (the cost of the policy). Higher deductibles usually result in lower premiums and vice versa. Consider your budget and how much you’re willing to pay out of pocket.

3. Reimbursement Percentage: Pet insurance policies typically reimburse you for eligible expenses after you’ve paid the deductible. The reimbursement percentage can vary from 70% to 90% or more. A higher percentage means the insurer covers a larger portion of your vet bills.

4. Maximum Payouts: Check if there are annual or lifetime maximum payout limits. Some policies have caps on how much they will pay out for a specific condition or over your pet’s lifetime. Ensure the limits align with your pet’s potential medical expenses.

5. Waiting Periods: Understand any waiting periods associated with the policy. Some insurance plans have waiting periods before coverage begins for specific conditions, so make sure you know when your pet will be fully covered.

6. Pre-Existing Conditions: Most pet insurance companies won’t cover pre-existing conditions. Be aware of how each insurer defines and handles pre-existing conditions, as this can impact your coverage.

7. Network of Veterinarians: Determine if the policy requires you to visit specific veterinarians or if you have the flexibility to choose any licensed vet. Having a broad network of providers can be essential for accessing care.

8. Claim Process: Learn about the claims process and how quickly you can expect to be reimbursed. Some insurers offer direct payment to veterinarians, while others require you to pay upfront and then submit a claim for reimbursement.

9. Customer Reviews and Reputation: Research customer reviews and the reputation of the insurance company. Look for feedback on their responsiveness, ease of filing claims, and overall customer satisfaction.

10. Exclusions and Waiting Periods: Pay attention to any exclusions or waiting periods for specific conditions or treatments. Some policies may not cover certain breeds or may exclude coverage for specific hereditary conditions.

11. Age and Breed of Your Pet: Consider your pet’s age and breed. Some policies may have age restrictions or breed-specific coverage limitations.

12. Additional Benefits: Some pet insurance plans offer additional benefits like coverage for lost pet advertising, boarding fees, or travel expenses. Evaluate these extras based on your needs and lifestyle.

Taking the time to carefully assess these factors will help you make an informed decision when choosing the right pet insurance policy for your beloved companion.

How We Evaluate Pet Insurance Companies

The staff at Hello Genius takes our reviews seriously and considers our decisions carefully. There are many pet insurance companies in the market but only a handful in our opinion can be considered among the best in the business.

We reviewed more than a dozen pet insurance companies and rated them against several important factors including overall experience, brand reputation, customer satisfaction, scope of coverage, and more.

When available we do participate in a company’s affiliate program so we can earn compensation should one of our readers sign up for their services. We do this so we can continue to provide valuable content without having to charge our readers to access this website.