5 Best Auto Insurance Companies of 2024

If you need help quickly and easily comparing the best auto insurance rates, you’ve come to the right place. We’ve done the detailed research so you don’t have to. See our top auto insurance picks below.

Last Updated: January 1, 2024

Lexington Law


  • Best rated overall auto insurance company

  • Competitive rates for expansive coverage

  • Multi-car and bundled coverage discounts available

  • Rideshare coverage available

Allstate Insurance Review


  • Best for discounts and savings

  • Industry-leading customer service

  • Fast and easy online quote experience

  • Qualify for Allstate’s pay-per-mile program for low mile drivers

State Farm

  • Best rates for senior drivers

  • Great coverage options for teen drivers and rentals

  • Bundle and save with other insurance products

  • Usage-based insurance program available

Liberty Mutual Insurance Review

Liberty Mutual

  • Best for bundled insurance savings

  • Low price gap insurance

  • New or better care replacement value coverage

  • Pay-per-mile insurance program available

Farmers Insurance Review

Farmers Insurance

  • Best for rideshare drivers

  • New car replacement and accident forgiveness available

  • Usage-based insurance program available for more savings

  • Bundle insurance for more savings

Hello Genius Auto Insurance Buyer’s Guide

Shopping for auto insurance is an important financial decision. Here’s what to look for when searching for a new auto insurance policy:

1. Coverage Types:
Understand the different types of coverage available, including liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, and more. Choose coverage that suits your needs.

2. State Requirements:
Ensure your policy meets the minimum insurance requirements in your state. Each state has different mandatory coverage levels.

3. Deductibles:
Decide on the deductibles for your policy. A higher deductible can lower your premium, but you’ll pay more out of pocket in case of a claim.

4. Premium Costs:
Get quotes from multiple insurance providers to compare premium costs. Keep in mind that the cheapest option may not provide the best coverage.

5. Discounts:
Inquire about discounts for which you may qualify, such as safe driving, good student, multi-policy, or anti-theft device discounts. These can significantly reduce your premium.

6. Coverage Limits:
Evaluate the coverage limits for bodily injury liability, property damage liability, and other coverage types. Ensure the limits meet your financial protection needs.

7. Claims Process:
Research the insurer’s reputation for claim processing. Read customer reviews and look for feedback regarding how quickly and efficiently claims are handled.

8. Customer Service:
Consider the insurance provider’s customer service reputation. Access to responsive and helpful customer service is essential.

9. Financial Strength:
Check the insurer’s financial strength rating from agencies like A.M. Best, Moody’s, or Standard & Poor’s to ensure they can meet their financial obligations.

10. Policy Discounts:
Find out if you qualify for any specific policy discounts, such as low mileage, usage-based insurance, or automatic payment discounts.

11. Optional Coverage:
Explore optional coverage types, such as roadside assistance, rental car coverage, and gap insurance, and decide if they’re worth adding to your policy.

12. Online Account Management:
Determine if the insurer offers online account management for policy changes, payments, and claim tracking.

13. Credit Score Impact:
Understand how obtaining insurance quotes can affect your credit score and inquire if a credit-based insurance score is used to determine your premium.

14. Policy Exclusions:
Read the policy carefully to understand any exclusions or limitations, such as coverage for certain perils or situations.

15. Transparency:
Choose an insurance provider that is transparent about policy terms, exclusions, and any fees associated with the policy. Read and understand the fine print.

16. Personal Recommendations:
Ask friends, family, or coworkers for recommendations or their experiences with their auto insurance providers.

17. Available Discounts:
Find out if you qualify for any available discounts, such as multi-car, defensive driving course completion, or affinity group discounts.

18. Accessibility:
Ensure the insurer has local agents or an easy-to-use website for managing your policy and making claims.

When shopping for auto insurance, remember that the right policy should provide the coverage you need at a price you can afford. It’s also important to periodically review your policy to ensure it continues to meet your changing needs and circumstances.

How We Evaluate Auto Insurance Companies

The staff at Hello Genius takes our reviews seriously and considers our decisions carefully. There are many auto insurance companies in the market but only a handful in our opinion can be considered among the best in the business.

We reviewed many auto insurance companies and rated them against several important factors including overall experience, brand reputation, customer satisfaction, scope of included services, fees, customer discounts and more.

When available we do participate in a company’s affiliate program so we can earn compensation should one of our readers sign up for their services. We do this so we can continue to provide valuable content without having to charge our readers to access this website.